“You Cannot Be Serious” – Why Tennis Needs to Deal with Player Discipline

Serena Williams v Kristie Ahn live streaming and predictions

In April, American tennis player Jared Donaldson spent more than a minute in an eyeball-to-eyeball confrontation with umpire Arnaut Gabas at the Monte Carlo Masters, when Gabas incorrectly ruled in a shot from his opponent.

The following month, former world number one, Karolina Pliskova, was so incensed at the end of a match in Rome that she literally bashed a hole in the umpire’s chair with her racquet frame.

And then spectators at the Nottingham Open final last week were treated to the sight of Britain’s Johanna Konta berating the umpire and shouting, “It’s an absolute joke. You’re making decisions that affect our lives. Do you fully understand that?”

Was the Sara Errani Doping Ban Wrong?

Player anger and dissent is nothing new in tennis, of course. Few can forget John McEnroe and his famous rants that became almost the same fundamental part of his game as his backhand and service.

McEnroe’s contemporary equivalent is probably Australian Nick Kyrgios, a serial offender, who threatened to stop playing in 2015 Wimbledon first round match against Diego Schwartmann and threw the words “dirty scum” in the direction of the umpire’s chair.

Karolina Pliskova FinedAnd even multiple Grand Slam winners are not immune, as evidenced by Serena Williams in the 2011 US Open Final, who told Greek umpire Eva Asderaki that she was “unattractive inside” and called her a “loser” before adding, “I completely despise you”.

Williams was fined US $2,000 for her outburst whilst the fine levied on Pliskova was described as being in “four figures”.

WTA Finals Live Streaming Here | ATP World Tour Finals Live Streaming Here

But is that enough? Pliskova has earned US $1.5 million in prize money so far this year alone and US $12.3 million over her career to date. Williams dwarfs that with career prize money of close to US $85 million.

And that is without taking into account the lucrative sponsorship deals both players have agreed. A fine of a few thousand dollars is just a drop in the ocean to such players, and offers no deterrent to them doing the same thing the next time – and the time after that, and the time after that.

Umpires do have the sanction of awarding penalty points and, in theory, can default a match but, in practice, these penalties are rarely applied.

Perhaps then it is time to introduce a card system, such as been used in football for years, and has since been adopted by other sports, such as Rugby, Hockey and even Cricket. Under such a system, a major outburst would be rewarded with a yellow card, and, in the severest of cases, a red.

Wimbledon Tips & Predictions Here | US Open Tips & Predictions Here

An accumulation of yellow cards would be totted-up, and, when a player had accumulated three or five, they would automatically miss a tournament. In the event of a red card, the player would automatically default the match and be forced to set out the next event, or even the one after that, if the offence committed was so grave.

This would really hit players in their pockets because they would be forced to forgo tournament winnings. It could also affect their world rankings, because they would earn no ranking points whilst sat on the side-lines.

Tennis is no longer the sedate polite game which had its origins in the English garden party. It is now a multi-billion dollar industry played by supreme athletes where the stakes are high and the competition intense. Yet the laws of the game and the treatment of on-court disciplinary issues belong to an earlier era.

Measures need to be taken to bring them in line with the modern game. Otherwise, one day a player will go too far, and, in the heat of the moment, angry over a missed line call or a service incorrectly called long, take their frustration out and seriously injure an umpire.

Tennis authorities need to look at this issue urgently, or the famous words of John McEnroe will become a prophecy – “you cannot be serious”.

Andy Dalziel
About Andy Dalziel 652 Articles
Andy is English but a long time resident of Cyprus. When not writing about tennis and other sports, he is also a Chartered Accountant. In his spare moments, he spends more time than is healthy worrying about his beloved Arsenal.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.